DJ Blog
 DJ Blog > Field of View Blog Edition: Do You Want Fries with That?

Do You Want Fries with That?
Posted by Chuck Peters on Thursday, February 28, 2008

The Lesson of Fast Food
Everything around us is becoming more modular and more scalable. Fast food may be the best example of this. Today’s fast food isn’t just fast; it’s customizable. I can get a #2 with no mustard and extra pickles, substitute onion rings for fries and get it with a shake instead of a soda. I can even get my kids Jolly Meals with fruit instead of fries. Back in the day, BK had a national ad campaign that was driven by the fact that you could "Have it your way” at their restaurants. Remember the jingle? "Hold the pickles, hold the lettuce special orders don’t upset us." At the time that was a big deal. Most people just ate it the way they made it or went somewhere else.

Our Way
Today, having it our way is the only way. We expect it. Who would accept anything less? The portions are scalable too. I can get my custom-created-just-to-my-liking #2 combo Regular size, Jumbo size or Gargantuan. It’s up to me! I like that. I bet you do too. As consumers, we all like to have things "our way." I think fast food chains have done a brilliant job of serving us their "content" in modular combinations and scalable portions.

The Challenge
As a video producer, writer and host, I wish that I could do that for my viewers. As producers, we face a dilemma when it comes to distributing our programs. There just isn’t a good way to create and present a video in a modular format that can be customized by the viewer on playback. We edit video in a nonlinear, random access fashion, but (with very few exceptions) our viewers still watch our productions as linear presentations. They start at the beginning and they have to watch the middle to get to the end. In my opinion, that’s too rigid for today’s busy, fast food content consumers.

One Possibility
Wouldn't it be cool if you could watch your own custom-created edit of a video, rather than being forced to settle for the one-size-fits-all option created for a mass audience? I think it would be cool to be able to offer my viewers optional 2-minute, 5-minute and 10-minute versions of a show and let them choose which version they'd like to watch. Sure, I could edit and distribute 3 or 4 versions of a show on DVD or post 4 versions to a web page, but that's way too time consuming and bandwidth intensive. It's not practical. What I want is a way to create one edit, the full-length version, and then embed invisible markers into the file to assign commands that would re-direct or re-sequence the show on the fly during playback based on the viewer's individual level of interest in the episode.

So, a short version of a Field of View episode, for instance, might play the opening, then seamlessly jump to a quick example, then skip to the "so what" part of the conclusion in a way that's totally seamless to the viewer.

QuickTime, Flash and DVD can all sort of do this, but none of them is meant to do this or makes it a fast and easy process for the editor and a high quality viewing experience for the viewer. My hope is that it won’t be long before we see this kind of technology built into editing applications.

I predict that, in the future, the way we distribute video will have to change to become more viewer-customizable. Our shows will need to become modular and scalable. Viewers want to watch videos on their own terms; they just don't know it yet! Until that day comes, they'll just have to watch what we give them… or exercise their right to turn us off.

Chuck Peters is VP of Media and Publications at Digital Juice and is an Emmy Award Winning writer and producer.



Views: 4064   Views Today: 2

Post Comments:
Want to post comments?
You must register for the DJ website and login
 

25 User Comments:

Does enibody knows what type of font is the one DJ uses for its logo?
Posted on 10/28/2009 by diegto torroija

That would be really cool, and i bet the guy that comes up with the solution will be filthy rich. If i remember right FoV was the first DJ i saw. cant wait for more.

I also agree with Charlie Reilly, it would be nice to be able to select a single JB or MDE and download it instead of paying hundreds for a package we have to wait to be shipped and probably only use a few of them.

I would also love to see paypal implemented into the checkout system cause thats the only way a 16 year old could get money online without begging the parents for their card.
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Aaron Blankenship

Good point...I think you are right, but at the same time that saddens me that in our time-constrained world the demands for this type of service is even there. On another note, you always have just the right analogy Chuck to relate "video speak" to other experiences. (My favorite analogy of yours is the one in episode # 10 of Field of View....the analogy of language and punctuation to understanding the meaning of video transitions and editing.) Thanks for always sharing your thoughts, insight and knowledge...It is highly valued!

Posted on 2/28/2008 by Coleen Lou, The Epstein School

Chuck, I've got good news for you. Accela Communications is doing what you suggest... kind of. Now, I don't work for them, but I have seen their presentation, been on the website, and had a webdemo from them. What they do is help you produce video content for your website. Then, they make the content searchable and viewing of the content non-linear. For now, its very expensive, and best used for sales or training videos on your corporate website. But it is exactly what you're talking about here.
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Brett Birdsong, Versatile Systems Inc.

Chuck, your FOV on DVD was one of my favorites from DJ. You should consider bringing them back for many of the reasons others have already posted. I would buy them. I have delivered DVD programs to clients with chapter breaks that seemed natural to the material in the program. Most of my programs are training videos with content divisions dictated by the customer. Documentaries I have done have been broken into groupings around the natural flow of the program, but they have been mostly the customer's choice. I guess what I am saying is, I trust my customers are getting what they want the way they want it - they keep coming back. Part of my job is to know my customer well enough or to make sure I involve them throughout the production process so that it is what they want. We talk abut the delivery issues up front. But am I missing something? From FOV and other training, video isn't "fast food for the eyes" and jerking viewers' brains around by jumping everywhere is counterintuitive.
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Lester Preiss, Dawn Video Productions

Interesting thought! Is DJ thinking of creating and then marketing something like you described? I hope so!
Thanks for FoV and look forward to viewing the DJTV episodes S-O-O-N....
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Eileen O'Neill

Neat proposal Chuck. As I read, I could envision you, on camera, in your passionate style, dispensing your pearls of wisdom. Now, if I could customize this blog, I'd have it as a full blown DJTV episode. Super well done - thanks for the insight.

However, I know that this would apply to everyone but me - my productions are so captivating that no one would want to miss a single minute - LOL
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Bill C. (aka wizard from the DJ Forums), Channell One Video

I agree with what Shawn said. Fast food and video are two different things. One is a physical product, the other is a means of portraying a concept. Apples and Oranges. If we could slim down the time it takes to portray a concept, I wouldn't be in college right now - I'd have finished it in the first year!

I remember at some point, you had stated in a FoV episode that the lingering camera and slower pace were intentional - this was unique to FoV. why now the interest in cutting to the chase?
At the same time, I think it's also our responsibility as producers to ensure that we're only 'fluffing' our productions. We need to make sure that every frame is relevant, and remove the ones that aren't. If a movie takes nine hours to tell a story (think Lord of the Rings), then there's an audience who will love it (my cousin and my best friend) and an audience who won't (me). That's part of video that we need to understand.

Joey
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Joey Famiglietti

Love my whopper my way! Double Whopper with Cheese extra heavy cheese cut in half! - now that is a sandwich. I only wish I could get McDonald fries with that. Or a Wendy Frosty or an Arbys potato cakes.
Makes me think - maybe to give another type of custom-created video another idea on the track you were talking about maybe we need to - well converge or juxtapose our ideas from more than one source. Even a collaboration with other producers, really adding what they see to what you see to deliver more choices more "Their Way" of thinking. Good Stuff Chuck - makes you wanna go hummmm
Steve
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Steve Dubrava, Perfect 10 Satellite Dist

Chuck, I suggest you check out sevenEcho's PIE platform, it is viewer customizable, it is personalized, it is modular, and it is scalable, and it is in use today to deliver entertainment television shows over the web in a form that is not old interactive, and not linear.
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Syd Weinstein

Great Blog though I do prefer watching videos(slow reader)
I recently made a promotional video for a missionary in Honduras where we made a 20 min video which had sections i.e. Building, Teaching, etc then gave them different options with and with out the intro. I use DVD Studio Pro and used what they call 'Stories'. It seemed to work well for them as most churches can only fit a 3min video in a service but in small groups or sunday school settings the longer versions work well.
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Andries Kleynhans, River Valley Community Church

Afterthought:

I compare Chucks scenario to the StackTraxx, etc. In the Juicer, you have the option of choosing the 10/15/30 second versions. .... If DJ were "old school", they would just post a full 3 minute version of the song and make you edit it to the time you wanted..... but I am glad DJ is way ahead of the game and gives us choices.

Hey DJ, I want the new ETK Pro library, but I want it with a blue box, purple discs, and a metal case for it.....LOL......now, that's a little bit too weird...LOL..... just stick a pickle and onions in it and I'll be happy...LOL
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Jerry Jones (aka Lthrboots from the DJ Forums), JGJ Media

Yeah, I don't really agree with this idea at all. Will it probably happen, yeah. That's sad though. People are moving so fast that they can't even have an attention span to watch a 22 min sit-com? (minus the commercials). Lame. You need that time to develop a plot and character story line and all that stuff. If you don't invest that time to do those things, what's the point in making a show?
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Jeff Paulus, WLIO-TV

We miss ya Chuck! That was one of the best show DJ did.
Adam
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Adam W. Hampton, ANR Productions

I agree Chuck....I have looked at the "placing markers" thing in videos, but never really delved into it deep enough to figure out what I could do with it yet.

I know you can place links into videos using some applications, and then have the viewer able to click links on the video and open a site or something....but like I said, I haven't played with this scenario enough yet to know what can, and can't , be done with it.

I hope your description of that scenario comes to pass really soon. That would be so cool........

Hey, even someone reading this message can jump to the end when they get tired of me babbling on and on and on about junk....LMAO

Thanks Chuck, for yet another interesting blog. You always pick at our brains and get us to think way beyond "outside the box".
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Jerry Jones (aka Lthrboots from the DJ Forums), JGJ Media

Just because you "could", doesn't mean you "should"! (ala Jurrasic Park)

I hope Doctors don't take your philosophy while learning in school to become a Doctor! Why go to school for 8 or so years when I can just do 2! Point is, there is a REASON why a producer "makes" you sit through an entire production from start to finish...it's so you get the complete message. Not just the fancy opener and conclusion. What did they learn by taking that shortcut? Next to nothing...a concept maybe...but definately NOT the info the producer wanted to share with them. Videos are not fast food. Thank God! Look at what fast food does to your body. (watch "Super Size Me" on DVD to get the full picture) Point is, it's not healthy for you. period. Your prediction I hope will be as precise as Nostradomus, because that style of production is simply not "healthy" for the viewer. Watch to learn or be entertained. If you want fast food television, watch the news! (let me tell ya how "healthy" THAT is for you!
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Shawn Beuscher, Imagine Studios

The consumer may not know it yet but business does, I was asked to scale down a 30 min. production i did for a Major food manufacture, they had some corporate folks visiting and wanted it all in 5 minutes. I did a 5, 15 and 30 minute on one DVD, they loved it and now they want everything that way, oh ya, I hate it, too much work, your right its comming. Good foresite
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Fred Barrett

In a way you can do this with DVDs instead of making one long video file break it up into smaller chunks. Then when you create your timelines either line up all of the "chunks" or leave out certain "chunks" now you have used up no additional space but have given your views 3, 4 or even 5 different edits. For a project like Stan A. mentioned this could be a perfect solution.
I have done this with a dance recital, one edit was the entire show in order, another was just the older kids, and the last was just the little kids. Each dance nunber was it's own mpeg.
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Brett B.

It's interesting that you would present this topic at this point in my career as a filmmaker. A few months ago, I finished my first feature-length film, a documentary about taking a group of college students on a civil rights tour of the south. Since I finished the 95-minute film, which includes a LOT of talking head, I also made a 45-minute version that's more like a travelogue and a 22-minute version that's really just the most significant "bullet points" of the journey. Now I can show my work to different kinds of audiences in different venues, giving it much more exposure than it would have had in the feature-length format.
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Stan Arthur, Stetson University

Interesting observation, and I like it. In fact, now I'm going to turn the tables on you guys at DJ... Often I'll be looking at your product offerings as something new comes out (I've spent CONSIDERABLE money on them), but I often find that because of the nature of the work I do (government agencies), few of the sets have more than one or two items I'll EVER get a chance to use. So since we are in a "Have it your way world", have you DJ folks ever considered making your products available as ala carte items (download only)? If I really really want a certain Jump Back, for instance, because it's the PERFECT thing for the current project, wouldn't it be great to be able to buy it on-line, pay with a card, and download that ONE item? We're in a very tight budget climate. I wonder if this idea has possibilities for your end of the business...?
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Charlie Reilly, VITA

This is an interesting point of view. I believe your idea would work wonderfully for what I produce. My audience ranges from scientists and engineers that want to see every detail, to the average Joe that just wants to know the overview and impact of the science. It would be great not to have different versions of the same thing.
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Brian Albin, U.S. Dept. of Energy/NETL

Great blog, Chuck. NOW GO MAKE MORE VIDEOS! <grin>
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Shaun Roemich, Gearhead Visual Productions

Thanks for the post...but I prefer to watch the videos of FoV instead of reading a blog, please come back...please!
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Juan Marcos Radziwiluk, Word of Life Ukraine

What is the rule of thumb... 10-15-5? Pretty much you can watch any show for the first 10min, then just to the middle want watch 15min then jump to the end and watch the last 5 min and completely get the jest of the show and understand! Hey, life itself is all about change, I agree we should all be looking for innovative ways at producing. Chuck your idea sounds like it could be incorporated easily into any type media player to just to a predefined set of "bookmarks", well see time will tell!
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Jeff Whitley

Cool post Chuck. FoV is my fave and good to get some reading in if there are no episodes. Thanks.
Posted on 2/28/2008 by Simon Dewar

Digital Juice Fonts
Editor's Themekit